Evaluation judges how effectively a writer achieves their purpose and considers alternative readings. For example: “Some critics see Antony as sincere. Arguably, though, his speech is carefully calculated to manipulate the crowd.”
Support evaluation with precise evidence and close analysis: “The cold, formal verb ‘dispensed’ suggests Jane is treated as a problem to be managed rather than a child to be loved.”
The best essays show a personal, thoughtful response grounded in the text: confident, tentative where appropriate, and always justified.
Worked example
Which phrase introduces an alternative interpretation? A: “For example,” B: “Arguably, though,” C: “In conclusion,”
- For example gives evidence.
- In conclusion sums up.
Answer:B: “Arguably, though,”
Key words
- evaluation
- judging effectiveness
- alternative reading
- another valid interpretation
- justified
- supported with evidence and reasons
Practise this
New questions every time.
Common Core-referenced: W.11-12.9